Skip to content
Christmas & Holiday Lights 2026Explore the community map

Civic Center & Charter

SF Weighs Fate of 850 Bryant St. as 2006 Ruling Clouds Term Limits

A Skidmore, Owings and Merrill study evaluates moving courts to 50 U.N. Plaza or 1455 Market St., while legal analysts point to a June 2006 Court of Appeal ruling suggesting Prop. A repealed Prop. B’s lifetime ban.

By SF Wall
Published · 3 min read

Neoclassical stone columns and modernist concrete civic buildings in San Francisco Civic Center in late afternoon sun
Late afternoon sunlight across neoclassical limestone and mid-century civic facades in San Francisco’s Civic Center district. · SF Wall photo illustration
Your listening Queue & catch up
Unheard stories first, timed at 1×. Your selections stay first.

Add a story or build a catch-up queue to start listening.

More than three decades after San Francisco's Hall of Justice at 850 Bryant St. was declared seismically unsafe in 1992, city officials are evaluating whether to demolish the complex completed in 1960 or relocate court operations to an existing commercial building, as reported by ABC7 News. The San Francisco Police Department exited the building in 2015, followed by the District Attorney's Office in 2017 under then-District Attorney George Gascón, while Jail No. 3 closed in 2010 and Jail No. 4 closed in 2020 with inmates transferred to 425 Seventh St. and San Bruno.

Today, the Superior Court is the primary tenant at 850 Bryant St., occupying 23% of the structure, where only one of the four main elevators was operating during a recent tour and District Attorney Brooke Jenkins recalled mice, ceiling leaks, and asbestos before her office's departure. Since 2008, four feasibility studies have examined replacements; the latest study this year by Lisa Follman of Skidmore, Owings and Merrill evaluated repurposing 1455 Market or 50 U.N. Plaza, which underwent a seismic, electrical, and plumbing retrofit in 2013 and was removed from a 2025 federal sale list.

Supervisor Matt Dorsey called the Hall of Justice an unacceptable seismic hazard identified for demolition and reflected on the Board of Supervisors' unanimous 2015 vote—backed by then-Supervisors London Breed and Jane Kim over warnings from then-Supervisor Scott Wiener—to reject an $80 million state jail grant. While San Francisco later opened a behavioral health stabilization unit at 822 Geary St. in 2025, launched the Reset Center this year, and used Proposition 1 funds to expand psychiatric beds at UCSF Health's Hyde hospital, any future courthouse replacement would not include a jail.

At City Hall, a separate legal debate has emerged in 2026 over whether November's Proposition A inadvertently repealed the lifetime supervisor term limits enacted by voters in June's Proposition B, according to an analysis by Tim Redmond in 48 Hills. Because Proposition A—sponsored by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman on behalf of the mayor in 2026—was drafted before Proposition B, it restated the old City Charter language allowing supervisors to serve two consecutive terms, though Mandelman and the City Attorney's Office argue the two measures can be harmonized.

Tenant attorney Mitchell Omerberg pointed to a parallel precedent directed by City Attorney press spokesperson Jen Kwart: after the Board of Supervisors and Mayor Willie Brown enacted the late Supervisor Sue Bierman's ordinance on Oct. 2, 1998 (effective Nov. 1) raising the owner-move-in eviction threshold from 25 percent to 50 percent, voters approved Proposition G in November 1998 (effective Dec. 18), which imposed a three-year ownership rule but accidentally retained the old 25 percent text. When landlord Leslie Garber bought a 25 percent interest at 1830 Gough St. and was challenged by Legal Assistance for the Elderly attorney Tom Drohan, the state Court of Appeal ruled in June 2006 that section 37.9(a)(8) was governed by the measure enacted last in time—a rule that could allow former supervisors such as Aaron Peskin to run again alongside incumbents such as Danny Sauter.

Sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought on this story.